Surgical Negligence Claims in Ireland: What Patients Need to Know

Surgical Negligence Solicitors Dublin: A Guide to Making a Medical Negligence Claim

What Is Surgical Negligence?

Common Surgical Errors That Give Rise to Claims

How Surgical Negligence Claims Work in Ireland

Evidence in a Surgical Negligence Claim

Time Limits for Surgical Negligence Claims

The Role of Anderson & Gallagher LLP in Surgical Negligence Claims

FAQs: Surgical Negligence Claims Ireland

What is the difference between a surgical complication and surgical negligence?

A surgical complication is an adverse outcome that falls within the range of recognised risks of the procedure, risks that a competent surgeon operating to the required standard might be unable to prevent. Surgical negligence arises when the harm was caused by a failure to meet the standard of care a reasonably competent surgeon in that speciality would have provided. The distinction can be complex and requires expert opinion to assess.

Do surgical negligence claims go through the Injuries Resolution Board?

No. Medical negligence claims, including surgical negligence claims, do not go through the Injuries Resolution Board. They are pursued directly through the courts, most commonly the High Court for claims of significant value.

How long does a surgical negligence claim take in Ireland?

The timeline varies considerably depending on the complexity of the case, the number of expert reports required, and whether the matter settles or proceeds to a contested hearing. Medical negligence claims typically take longer than standard personal injury claims. Some cases settle within one to two years of instruction; others, particularly those involving complex causation questions or contested liability, take longer.

What medical records will I need for a surgical negligence claim?

We will obtain a complete set of your medical records as part of the initial steps in any medical negligence case. These include operative notes, anaesthetic records, consent documentation, nursing records, test results and post-operative notes. Patients are entitled to access their medical records under data protection law, and Anderson & Gallagher LLP can assist in obtaining these on your behalf.

How is compensation assessed in surgical negligence cases?

Compensation in medical negligence cases is assessed by the courts and takes into account general damages for the pain, suffering and loss of quality of life caused by the injury, as well as special damages covering financial losses such as loss of earnings, the cost of additional treatment or care required as a result of the negligence, and future expenses where relevant.
Yes. Signing a consent form confirms that a patient was given certain information and agreed to proceed with the procedure. It does not waive your right to claim where the surgery itself was carried out negligently, or where the consent process failed to disclose a material risk that subsequently occurred and that you were not adequately informed about.

Informed consent means that a patient has been provided with sufficient information about a proposed procedure, including its significant risks, to make a voluntary and informed decision about whether to proceed. Under Irish law, following the Supreme Court judgment in Geoghegan v Harris, the standard for disclosure of risk is patient-centred: the question is what a reasonable patient would want to know, not simply what a medical practitioner would think necessary to disclose.

Conclusion