Surgery carries inherent risks that every patient accepts when they consent to a procedure. However, there is a clear legal and ethical distinction between an accepted surgical risk and an avoidable error caused by a failure to meet the required standard of care. Where a surgeon or medical team falls below that standard, and a patient suffers harm as a result, a surgical negligence claim may arise. This guide explains what surgical negligence involves under Irish law, what types of errors most commonly give rise to claims, how claims are processed, what evidence is needed, and when speaking with a medical negligence solicitor in Dublin is the right step to take.
Surgical negligence is a category of medical negligence that arises when a surgeon, anaesthetist, theatre team, or other surgical professional fails to provide the standard of care that a reasonably competent practitioner in their speciality would have provided, and that failure causes harm to the patient.
It is important to understand that not every poor surgical outcome amounts to negligence. Surgery is a complex and inherently risky field. Complications can occur even when every aspect of a procedure has been carried out to the highest professional standard. A patient who experiences a recognised complication of their surgery, one that was disclosed in the pre-operative consent process, does not automatically have a claim.
The question Irish law asks is whether the treatment received fell below the standard of a responsible body of medical opinion within that speciality. This is known as the Dunne v National Maternity Hospital test in Irish law, drawing on principles established in English case law. If a defendant can show that their conduct was supported by a responsible body of similar specialists, a negligence claim will generally fail on breach of duty, even where the outcome was poor.
Where a claim succeeds, it is because the evidence establishes that the error was not a recognised risk but an avoidable failure and that this failure caused identifiable harm to the patient.
While every case is different, certain categories of surgical error appear most frequently in medical negligence claims in Ireland.
Operating on the wrong site, organ or patient is among the most serious and most clearly indefensible categories of surgical error. These events, sometimes called “never events”, represent failures of basic surgical safety protocols and are rarely justifiable as accepted risk.
Leaving surgical instruments or materials inside a patient following a procedure is another serious and unfortunately not uncommon category. Retained swabs, clamps or other instruments may go undetected for weeks, months or even years and can cause serious ongoing harm, including infection, perforation, and chronic pain.
Nerve damage caused during surgery may be a recognised risk of certain procedures, but it may also result from a failure in technique or surgical planning. Where nerve damage is caused by error rather than accepted risk, it may give rise to a claim.
Anaesthetic errors, including incorrect dosing, failure to monitor patient response, or failure to respond appropriately to complications during the administration of anaesthesia, can have devastating consequences and are a recognised basis for surgical negligence claims.
Inadequate pre-operative assessment or planning, where a surgeon proceeds with a procedure without taking appropriate steps to assess patient fitness, identify contraindications or consider alternative approaches, may give rise to liability if harm results.
Failure to obtain proper informed consent is a distinct but related category. Patients in Ireland have the right to receive sufficient information about a proposed procedure, including its material risks, to make an informed decision about whether to proceed. Where a patient was not informed of a significant risk that subsequently materialised, and where a reasonable patient in their position would have declined the procedure or sought an alternative had they known, a claim may arise even where the surgical technique itself was otherwise competent.
Post-operative care failures, inadequate monitoring, failure to recognise and respond to signs of complication, delayed treatment of surgical site infection or haemorrhage, can also form the basis of a claim where they cause or worsen harm.
Read More: Injury by Defective Medical Devices in Ireland: What Patients Should Know
Medical negligence claims in Ireland, including surgical negligence claims, follow a different procedural pathway from standard personal injury claims. They do not go through the Injuries Resolution Board. Instead, they are pursued directly through the courts, with the High Court typically handling claims of significant value.
The process begins with a letter of claim to the relevant hospital, healthcare provider or clinician. This sets out the nature of the alleged negligence and the harm suffered. The defendant has an opportunity to respond, and in many cases, discussions and correspondence between legal teams take place before any court proceedings are issued.
Medical negligence claims require independent expert opinion to proceed. At Anderson & Gallagher LLP, once we are instructed, we obtain your full medical records and engage independent medical experts in the relevant speciality to assess whether the treatment you received met the required standard of care. If the expert opinion supports a claim, proceedings are structured and issued.
Because of this requirement for expert assessment, medical negligence claims typically take longer to progress than standard personal injury claims. The timeline varies considerably depending on the complexity of the case, the availability of expert opinion and whether the matter proceeds to a contested hearing or settles before trial.
The central evidence in any surgical negligence claim is the patient’s medical record. This includes the operative notes, anaesthetic records, consent documentation, nursing and post-operative notes, and all correspondence and test results before and after the procedure. Obtaining a complete and accurate set of medical records at the outset is a critical first step.
In addition to the medical records, expert opinion from independent consultants in the relevant speciality is essential. These experts review the records and provide opinion on whether the treatment fell below the required standard and, if so, whether that failure caused the harm suffered by the patient. A “causation” expert, often a different specialist, may also be required to assess whether the negligent act or omission was the cause of the damage, rather than the underlying condition or other factors.
Patients often feel uncertain about whether they have sufficient evidence to proceed. The starting point is not a complete evidential file; it is simply your account of what happened and access to your medical records. From there, an experienced medical negligence solicitor can advise on whether the circumstances warrant further investigation and expert assessment.
The standard time limit for medical negligence claims in Ireland is two years from the date of the incident or, where the patient was unaware of the connection between the treatment and the harm, two years from the date of knowledge. This date of knowledge rule is particularly relevant in surgical negligence cases, because complications from surgery can sometimes take months or years to manifest fully or to be correctly attributed.
For claims involving minors, the two-year period begins from the date of their eighteenth birthday.
These time limits are strict, and delay in seeking legal advice can seriously prejudice a potential claim. If you are considering a surgical negligence claim, early consultation with a solicitor is advisable even if the full facts are not yet clear to you.
Anderson & Gallagher LLP has been advising and representing clients in medical negligence matters for over 40 years. Our medical negligence team, led by Senior Solicitor Keira O’Reilly, handles complex surgical negligence cases with sensitivity, thoroughness, and a focus on achieving the best possible outcome for each client.
We understand that patients who come to us following a surgical injury are often in ongoing pain or difficulty, emotionally affected by what has happened, and sometimes uncertain whether what they experienced was negligent. Our role is to help you understand your situation clearly, to investigate the claim properly, and to guide you through the legal process with as little additional stress as possible.
We advise clients in English, Polish and Ukrainian, and we have extensive experience representing clients across a wide range of surgical specialities including orthopaedics, gynaecology, general surgery, cardiac surgery and neurosurgery.
Informed consent means that a patient has been provided with sufficient information about a proposed procedure, including its significant risks, to make a voluntary and informed decision about whether to proceed. Under Irish law, following the Supreme Court judgment in Geoghegan v Harris, the standard for disclosure of risk is patient-centred: the question is what a reasonable patient would want to know, not simply what a medical practitioner would think necessary to disclose.
Surgical negligence claims are among the most legally and medically complex personal injury cases in Irish law. They require careful investigation, expert medical opinion, and experienced legal representation. If you believe you or a family member has been harmed by a surgical error, the first step is to seek advice from a solicitor with specific expertise in medical negligence.
Anderson & Gallagher LLP has over 40 years of experience in this field. We handle each case with the care and attention it deserves, and we will take the time to explain your position and options clearly before any decisions are made. Contact us on our freephone number 1800 200 618, call us on 01 677 6066, or email info@andersongallagher.ie to arrange a consultation.
Disclaimer: This content is provided for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not, and cannot be construed as, professional legal advice. Since laws and specific circumstances apply to every unique case, you should not rely on this article as a substitute for consulting a qualified solicitor. For advice on your specific situation, please contact Anderson & Gallagher LLP.
In contentious business, a solicitor may not calculate fees or other charges as a percentage or proportion of any award or settlement.