Being injured by a product you trusted is a deeply unsettling experience, and it raises an immediate and pressing question: what can you do about it? If you have suffered a defective product injury in Ireland, the law is on your side. Read on to learn which legislation protects you, who can be held responsible, and how the claims process works. For clear, tailored advice, contact Anderson & Gallagher LLP in Dublin today.
Faulty products cause serious injuries to consumers in Ireland every year. A kitchen appliance that overheats and burns its user. A child’s toy with a component that breaks off and causes choking. A piece of sports equipment that fails mid-use, sending someone to the emergency department. A vehicle tyre that blows out on the motorway without warning. In each case, a person goes about their ordinary life, uses a product as it was intended to be used, and suffers harm that should never have happened.
The common thread running through all of these situations is that the injury was preventable. A manufacturer, importer, or retailer placed an unsafe product on the market, and a consumer paid the price. Irish law provides a specific legal framework to deal with exactly this kind of harm, and Anderson & Gallagher LLP has the experience to help you use it.
The cornerstone of consumer protection in this area is the Liability for Defective Products Act 1991, which implemented European Council Directive 85/374/EEC into Irish law. The Act introduced a principle known as strict liability, and this is the most important concept for any injured consumer to understand. Under strict liability, you do not need to prove that the manufacturer was careless or reckless. You do not need to show that they cut corners or ignored warnings. What you need to show is:
This is a significantly lower burden of proof than traditional negligence, where you would have to demonstrate a failure of reasonable care at every step of the production process. Strict liability places the focus firmly on the product itself, rather than on the conduct of those who made it. The Act was amended in 2000 to bring primary agricultural products and game within its scope, following Council Directive 1999/34/EC. This means that contaminated food products, including unprocessed agricultural produce, can also give rise to a claim.
The 1991 Act defines a product as defective if it fails to provide the level of safety that a person is generally entitled to expect. This is a broad and consumer-focused standard. It is not about whether the product was the safest model on the market or whether a safer design existed; it is about whether its safety fell below a reasonable expectation.
Three types of defect typically arise in claims:
Manufacturing defects occur when a product departs from its intended design during the production process. A batch of medicines contaminated during bottling, or a structural component in a vehicle fitted incorrectly on the assembly line, are examples of manufacturing defects. The rest of the product range may be perfectly safe; the problem lies with the specific unit that caused the injury.
Design defects arise when the product was made exactly as intended but the design itself is unsafe. If an entire range of electrical heaters is designed with components that are prone to overheating, every unit in that range carries the same inherent risk. The defect is baked into the blueprint rather than introduced during production.
Instruction defects concern products that are inherently dangerous when used in a particular way but which come without adequate warnings or instructions. A cleaning product that releases toxic fumes when mixed with another common substance, but carries no warning to that effect, may be considered defective on this basis even if the chemical composition itself is standard.
One of the most practical features of the 1991 Act is that it extends liability across the entire supply chain, not just to the original manufacturer. Depending on the circumstances, the following parties may be liable:
The producer is the primary liable party. This is the person who manufactured the finished product, or who produced a raw material that was incorporated into the product. It also includes anyone who presents themselves as the producer by placing their name, trademark, or distinguishing feature on the product.
The importer can be held liable where a product was produced outside the European Economic Area and imported into Ireland or the EU. If you cannot identify the manufacturer, the importer who brought the product into circulation within the EEA steps into the producer’s shoes for the purposes of liability.
The supplier may be liable where the producer or importer cannot be identified, and the supplier fails to identify either of those parties within a reasonable time of being asked. In practice, this means that a retailer who sold you a product could face liability if the chain of supply cannot be traced back to the manufacturer.
This matters enormously in practice. Irish consumers often buy goods from international online platforms where the original manufacturer may be located in a jurisdiction outside the EEA, or where the brand on the packaging does not correspond to the actual producer. The provisions relating to importer and supplier liability ensure that there is a realistic party within the jurisdiction against whom a claim can be brought.
Defective product claims in Ireland are subject to a three-year limitation period, which is different from the two-year period that applies to most personal injury claims. Under Section 7 of the 1991 Act, this three-year period runs from the date on which the cause of action accrued, or from the date on which the injured person became aware, or should reasonably have become aware, of the damage, the defect, and the identity of the producer, whichever is the later date.
This “date of knowledge” provision is particularly important in cases involving latent harm, for example, where a medical device implanted years ago has been slowly causing internal damage, or where the effects of ingesting a contaminated product only become apparent over time.
However, there is a hard backstop under Section 7(2) of the Act: a right of action is extinguished ten years after the date on which the producer first put the specific product into circulation, unless proceedings have already been issued before that point. This means that regardless of when you became aware of the harm, you cannot bring a claim under the 1991 Act in respect of a product that has been in circulation for more than ten years. Given the complexity of calculating these time limits, particularly in cases involving delayed discovery of harm, it is important to seek legal advice as soon as possible.
While the law covers any product that fails to meet a reasonable safety standard, some categories of claim arise more frequently than others in the Irish context:
Household appliances and electrical goods are a consistent source of injury. Faulty wiring, overheating components, or inadequately shielded elements can cause burns, fires, or electric shocks. These incidents often cause significant property damage in addition to personal injury.
Food and beverages give rise to claims where contamination, mislabelling, or inadequate food safety processes expose consumers to illness. Irish food safety law works alongside the 1991 Act to provide overlapping protection in this area.
Motor vehicle components including tyres, braking systems, and steering components can cause catastrophic accidents when they fail. The consequences of a defective vehicle part at speed are often severe, and claims in this area can involve complex engineering evidence.
Children’s toys and equipment are subject to particular scrutiny because the potential victims are among the most vulnerable. Small detachable parts, toxic materials, or structural weaknesses that would not trouble an adult can pose serious dangers to young children.
Cosmetics and personal care products that cause allergic reactions or chemical burns may give rise to claims, particularly where the product did not carry adequate warnings about ingredients or where it was contaminated during manufacture.
The steps you take in the hours and days following an injury from a defective product can have a significant effect on the strength of your claim. Here is what we advise:
Seek medical attention straight away. Your health comes first, and a contemporaneous medical record of your injuries is one of the most important pieces of evidence in any personal injury claim. Do not minimise your symptoms; describe everything to your treating doctor.
Keep the product. Do not throw away the item that caused your injury, even if it has been damaged. The product itself, in the condition it was in after the incident, is a key piece of evidence. Store it safely and do not attempt to repair or clean it.
Preserve the packaging and any documentation. Keep the original packaging, the receipt or proof of purchase, any warranty documents, and the instruction manual if one was provided. These details establish when and where you bought the product and who manufactured it.
Photograph everything. Take photographs of the product, the packaging, the scene of the accident, and your injuries. If the injury involved a household appliance, photograph the room and any damage caused. Photographs provide a visual record that is difficult to challenge later.
Note the details of the incident. Write down what happened as soon as you are able to do so. Record the time and date, what you were doing with the product, and precisely how the injury occurred. Memory fades quickly, and a contemporaneous note carries significant evidential weight.
Report the incident. If the product was purchased from an Irish retailer, notify them. If the product is a consumer good, you may also consider reporting it to the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC), which has responsibility for product safety enforcement in Ireland.
Most personal injury claims in Ireland, including those arising from defective products, must first be submitted to the Injuries Resolution Board (IRB), the statutory body formerly known as PIAB. The IRB acts as an independent assessor of compensation where liability is not actively disputed.
At Anderson & Gallagher LLP, we guide you through each stage of this process:
We begin by taking a detailed statement from you about the incident and your injuries, and we advise you on the strength of your claim and the most appropriate course of action. We then gather the evidence needed to support your case: medical reports from your treating doctor and, where necessary, from an independent specialist; engineering or technical expert reports addressing the nature of the defect; and documentation establishing the identity of the producer and the product’s chain of supply.
Your claim is submitted to the IRB with a full medical report. The IRB will determine whether to accept the claim for assessment. If the respondent consents to assessment and the Board proceeds, you may also be asked to attend an independent medical examination. The Board will then issue a formal assessment of your entitlement to compensation.
If the respondent refuses to participate in the IRB process, or if either party considers the assessment unfair, the Board issues an Authorisation that allows court proceedings to be issued. Cases involving complex technical questions about product defects, or where the manufacturer disputes the existence of a defect entirely, may require expert testimony and are litigated through the courts.
Compensation in a defective product claim is divided into two broad categories.
General damages cover the pain and suffering caused by the injury, the impact on your daily life and activities, and any lasting physical or psychological effects. The amount depends on the severity of the injury and the expected recovery period, assessed against the Personal Injuries Guidelines introduced in 2021.
Special damages reimburse you for actual financial losses caused by the injury. This includes the cost of medical treatment, physiotherapy, and any other healthcare expenses, as well as loss of earnings if your injury kept you away from work and any other out-of-pocket costs arising directly from the incident.
You should keep careful records of all financial losses, retaining receipts and invoices from the date of the injury onwards.
Irish law provides robust protection for consumers who are injured by defective products, and the Liability for Defective Products Act 1991 means you do not have to prove that a manufacturer was negligent in order to pursue a claim. Whether the defect lay in the design, the production process, or the instructions provided with the product, the key questions are whether it was defective, whether it caused your injury, and whether you used it as intended. Preserving evidence, seeking medical attention promptly, and taking legal advice without delay are the three most important steps you can take after an injury of this kind.
At Anderson & Gallagher LLP, our solicitors have the experience and the commitment to guide you through this process clearly and efficiently. If you have been injured by a faulty or dangerous product, we can help you understand your legal position and take the right steps. Contact Anderson & Gallagher LLP to discuss your situation in confidence.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. For advice on your specific situation, please contact Anderson & Gallagher LLP. In contentious business, a solicitor may not calculate fees or other charges as a percentage or proportion of any award or settlement.
Related Services